| 15050 | Card | By Mail | 1987t | | premium members only |
| 23606 | Card | By Mail | 1989 Fleer #205 - Pittsburgh Pirates - blue sharpie - ex | | premium members only |
| 25373 | Card | By Mail | 1990 Fleer #464 - Pittsburgh Pirates - black sharpie - nmmt | | premium members only |
| 65647 | Card | By Mail | 90 Fleer #464 Pirates (black sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 70548 | Card | In Person | 1989 Fleer #205 Pirates blue | | premium members only |
| 103459 | Card | In Person | 1989 Fleer #205 Pirates blue | | premium members only |
| 110818 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps #651 Black Sharpie PIRATES
| | premium members only |
| 119118 | Card | By Mail | 1985 Topps #162 Black Sharpie PIRATES
| | premium members only |
| 173923 | Card | In Person | 1990 Fleer signed in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 176593 | Card | In Person | 1990 Fleer #464 in blue (Pirates) | | premium members only |
| 176594 | Card | In Person | 1989 Fleer #205 in blue (Pirates) | | premium members only |
| 180004 | Card | In Person | 1985 Topps signed in blue sharpie. | | premium members only |
| 180013 | Card | In Person | 1987 Topps signed in blue sharpie. | | premium members only |
| 185554 | Card | By Mail | 87T and 87D Pirates signed in black sharpie. Happy to send scans. | | premium members only |
| 222207 | Card | By Mail | 1989 Fleer (Pirates, black ink) | | premium members only |
| 222223 | Card | By Mail | 1990 Fleer (Pirates, black ink) | | premium members only |
| 228337 | Card | By Mail | 85 Topps #162 Pirates (black sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 228338 | Card | By Mail | 86 Donruss #78 Pirates (blue sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 228339 | Card | By Mail | 87 Topps #651 Pirates (blue sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 228340 | Card | By Mail | 89 Fleer #250 Pirates (blue sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 247562 | Card | In Person | 1989 Topps Traded #25T, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 249184 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps | | premium members only |
| 252401 | Card | By Mail | 1990 Fleer - blue | | premium members only |
| 256788 | Card | By Mail | | | premium members only |
| 258121 | Card | By Mail | 1987 topps signed in black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 283612 | Card | In Person | 1987 Topps, 1990 Fleer (Pirates) blue Sharpie | | premium members only |
| 293685 | Card | Trade | 1990 fleer #464 Pittsburgh pirates blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 295377 | Card | By Mail | 1990 Fleer #464 | | premium members only |
| 295378 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Donruss #514 | | premium members only |
| 295379 | Card | By Mail | 1989 ProCards #1682 | | premium members only |
| 295380 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Line Drive #454 | | premium members only |
| 295992 | Card | Trade | 1985 Topps | | premium members only |
| 300731 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps 651;
1989 Fleer 205;
1989 Topps Traded 25T;
1991 Line Drive AAA 454 | | premium members only |
| 302622 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps #651; Pirates | | premium members only |
| 309574 | Card | In Person | 1985 Donruss - blue sharpie PIRATES | | premium members only |
| 309579 | Card | In Person | 1986 Donruss - blue sharpie PIRATES | | premium members only |
| 309676 | Card | In Person | 1989 Fleer - blue sharpie PIRATES | | premium members only |
| 312621 | Card | By Mail | 1987 topps/ black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 321069 | Card | In Person | 1987 Topps - blue sharpie PIRATES | | premium members only |
| 321509 | Card | By Mail | 1985 Topps #162, blue sharpie PIRATES | | premium members only |
| 321579 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps #651, blue sharpie PIRATES | | premium members only |
| 334678 | Card | In Person | 1990 Fleer #464 - Pittsburgh Pirates |  | premium members only |
| 334679 | Card | In Person | 2008 West Michigan White Caps #28 - Detroit Tigers | | premium members only |
| 338143 | Card | By Mail | 1985 Donruss, 1985 Topps, 1990 Fleer (Pirates)- signed in blue | | premium members only |
| 341397 | Card | Trade | Autographed 1990 Fleer trading card #464. (Pittsburgh Pirates) | | premium members only |
| 356100 | Card | In Person | 1990 Benny Distefano Fleer Baseball Card #464, signed in blue, Quantity of 2 | | premium members only |
| 358616 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Donruss #514; Pirates (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
