| 50232 | Card | In Person | 1981 Topps 281 (Blue Sharpie) Yankees | | premium members only |
| 72563 | Card | By Mail | 1980 Topps #387 Yankees black | | premium members only |
| 76838 | Card | By Mail | 1978 TOPPS #664 IN BLUE YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 76864 | Card | By Mail | 1981 Topps #281 | | premium members only |
| 76865 | Card | By Mail | 1981 Donruss #585 | | premium members only |
| 119940 | Card | Bought | 1972 Topps Indians #1 |  | premium members only |
| 119941 | Card | Bought | 1972 Topps Indians #2 | | premium members only |
| 136921 | Card | By Mail | 1982 Topps in blue sharpie. | | premium members only |
| 141801 | Card | By Mail | 1974 Topps, YANKEES, blue. | | premium members only |
| 158252 | Card | By Mail | 1981 Donruss #585 | | premium members only |
| 158253 | Card | By Mail | 1975 Topps #503 | | premium members only |
| 158254 | Card | By Mail | 1978 Topps #664 | | premium members only |
| 158255 | Card | By Mail | 1979 Topps #16 | | premium members only |
| 160000 | Card | By Mail | 1978 Topps card# 664 signed | | premium members only |
| 173261 | Card | By Mail | 1982 Topps 787 Fred Stanley | | premium members only |
| 173262 | Card | By Mail | 1981 Topps 281 Blue Sharpie | | premium members only |
| 173263 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Topps 513 Blue Sharpie | | premium members only |
| 195164 | Card | By Mail | 1994 Brewers 25th Ann | | premium members only |
| 195165 | Card | By Mail | 1972 Topps #59 | | premium members only |
| 195166 | Card | By Mail | 1982 Topps #787 | | premium members only |
| 205003 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Topps #513 Blue Sharpie ATHLETICS | | premium members only |
| 205343 | Card | By Mail | 1974 TOPPS #423 IN BLUE YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 205344 | Card | By Mail | 1975 TOPPS #503 IN BLUE YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 205346 | Card | By Mail | 1972 TOPPS #59 IN BLUE INDIANS | | premium members only |
| 205904 | Card | By Mail | 81 donruss | | premium members only |
| 215206 | Card | By Mail | 1981 Topps Fred Stanley in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 215420 | Card | By Mail | 81 Topps #281-Yankees-black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 217108 | Card | Trade | 1972 Topps #59 Indians BL | | premium members only |
| 219481 | Card | Trade | 1976 Topps | | premium members only |
| 270732 | Card | By Mail | 1981 Fleer - blue | | premium members only |
| 274477 | Card | By Mail | 1979 Topps Burger King Fred Stanley in black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 288536 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Donruss Yankees in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 289869 | Card | Trade | 1983 Donruss | | premium members only |
| 290000 | Card | By Mail | Yankees The Wiz '70s, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 303727 | Card | By Mail | 1980 Topps #387; Yankees | | premium members only |
| 304793 | Card | By Mail | 1982 Fleer #108 — Blue | | premium members only |
| 307772 | Card | In Person | 1992 Yankees Wiz - blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 308253 | Card | In Person | 1981 Topps - blue sharpie YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 310469 | Card | By Mail | 1974 Topps - New York Yankees | | premium members only |
| 310470 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Topps - Oakland A's | | premium members only |
| 310675 | Card | By Mail | 1978 Topps #664; Yankees | | premium members only |
| 315863 | Card | Bought | 1982 Topps #787 - blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 318285 | Card | By Mail | 1977 Topps #123; Yankees | | premium members only |
| 319548 | Card | By Mail | 1976 Topps #429; Yankees | | premium members only |
| 320948 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Donruss in blue (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| 326869 | Card | By Mail | 1978 Topps, 1981 Topps (Yankees), 1982 Donruss (A's)- signed in blue | | premium members only |
| 330768 | Card | By Mail | index card - blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 338709 | Card | By Mail | 1978 Topps #664 - blue fine ink | | premium members only |
| 338714 | Card | By Mail | 1979 Topps #16 - blue fine ink | | premium members only |
| 338834 | Card | By Mail | 1982 Donruss #449 - blue fine ink | | premium members only |
| 347624 | Card | By Mail | 1976 SSPC #442; Yankees | | premium members only |
| 348593 | Card | By Mail | 1979 Topps #16; Yankees | | premium members only |
| 352521 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Fleer #534 | | premium members only |
| 352522 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Donruss #197 | | premium members only |
| 352523 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Topps #513 | | premium members only |
| 354868 | Card | Bought | 1983 Topps # 513 black fine point | | premium members only |
| 354939 | Card | By Mail | 1972 topps #59 signed blue | | premium members only |
| 359524 | Card | Trade | 83 Topps #513-A's-blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 264785 | Index Card | By Mail | World Series Champ 1977, 1978 ...... Seattle Pilots (1969)
Milwaukee Brewers (1970)
Cleveland Indians (1971–1972)
San Diego Padres (1972)
New York Yankees (1973–1980)
Oakland Athletics (1981–1982) | | premium members only |
