| 70509 | Card | By Mail | 2004 Fleer #129 Pirates black | | premium members only |
| 88122 | Card | By Mail | 01 Topps #483 Cubs (black sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 92841 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Topps total #207 | | premium members only |
| 120267 | Card | By Mail | 1999 Metal Universe | | premium members only |
| 120268 | Card | By Mail | 1999 Upper Deck | | premium members only |
| 120769 | Card | In Person | 2008 Topps Heritage #703Blue Phillies | | premium members only |
| 143316 | Card | In Person | 1993 Classic Best in black. | | premium members only |
| 168797 | Card | Bought | 2006 Fleer #338 Royals.....I am looking to trade this card for a signed item of Stairs in a Brewers uniform | | premium members only |
| 205112 | Card | By Mail | 2004 Topps TOtal - Royals |  | premium members only |
| 205139 | Card | Trade | 2000 Topps - A's | | premium members only |
| 223259 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Topps #469 Black Sharpie ROYALS | | premium members only |
| 230312 | Card | By Mail | 06 Topps Update #UH82 Tigers (black sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 230313 | Card | By Mail | 08 Upper Deck First Edition #32 Blue Jays (black sharpie) | | premium members only |
| 236012 | Card | In Person | 2000 Skybox Dominion #77, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 236324 | Card | In Person | 2008 Upper Deck #39, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 247302 | Card | In Person | 2009 Topps #139, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 259010 | Card | In Person | 00 Topps, 01 Ultra, 00 MVP, 98 Collector's Choice A's, 01 Topps Cubs, 09 Topps Update, 09 Topps Phillies, 11 Topps Update Nationals, 03 Tradition Brewers Blue | | premium members only |
| 262480 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Fleer Royals in Blue | | premium members only |
| 312923 | Card | By Mail | 2006 Fleer. Black sharpie. | | premium members only |
| 314704 | Card | By Mail | 1999 Upper Deck MVP #152 A’s | | premium members only |
| 321218 | Card | In Person | 2010 Topps - blue sharpie NATIONALS | | premium members only |
| 322348 | Card | In Person | 2008 Upper Deck First Edition - blue sharpie BLUE JAYS | | premium members only |
| 330093 | Card | By Mail | 1998 Topps #16 A’s | | premium members only |
| 336553 | Card | Trade | 1999 Topps Stadium Club #262 (blue sharpie) A's | | premium members only |
| 336554 | Card | Trade | 1999 Topps Stadium Club #262 (blue sharpie) A's | | premium members only |
| 349494 | Card | By Mail | 1992 Upper Deck Expos black | | premium members only |
| 351191 | Card | By Mail | 1992 Upper Deck | | premium members only |
| 353820 | Card | Bought | 1992 Upper Deck - blue sharpie EXPOS | | premium members only |
| 355476 | Card | Private Signing | 2006 Fleer | | premium members only |
| 359807 | Card | By Mail | 2002 Topps Total #851 Brewers | | premium members only |
