| 3076 | Card | By Mail | Champions for Today Bible card signed in black sharpie, ex Packers All Pro D-Lineman | | premium members only |
| 58036 | Card | By Mail | 1990 Collegiate Collection Notre Dame #64 signed in black sharpie |  | premium members only |
| 128306 | Card | By Mail | 1974 Topps #425 | | premium members only |
| 128307 | Card | By Mail | 1972 Topps #172 | | premium members only |
| 128308 | Card | By Mail | 1972 Topps #260 | | premium members only |
| 163888 | Card | By Mail | 3 small (but larger than card size) Packers promo cards signed in black sharpie. Happy to send scan. | | premium members only |
| 166239 | Card | By Mail | Packers cards provided by McCoy of him in a Packers uniform, signed in black sharpie (one is personalized and one is smudged) | | premium members only |
| 167971 | Card | By Mail | 1971 Topps #248 | | premium members only |
| 176943 | Card | Trade | 1977 Topps #44 - Packers | | premium members only |
| 206988 | Card | By Mail | 1971 Topps #248 rookie | | premium members only |
| 206989 | Card | By Mail | 1974 Topps #425 | | premium members only |
| 206990 | Card | By Mail | 1975 Topps #362 | | premium members only |
| 206991 | Card | By Mail | 1976 Topps #262 | | premium members only |
| 206992 | Card | By Mail | Champions for Today card | | premium members only |
| 250497 | Card | By Mail | Christian Bible Card - Green Bay Packers | | premium members only |
| 270493 | Card | By Mail | personal card provided by Mr. McCoy - black - (4) available | | premium members only |
| 283808 | Card | Bought | 1972 Topps - #260 - Green Bay Packers - Signed in Black Sharpie | | premium members only |
